He registered something was off.
“I need to ask you something, and I need you to be honest with me, Dan.”
“Okay.” He settled in, still relaxed, still performing casually. “What’s going on?”
“Mom’s necklace,” I probed. “The green stone pendant she wore her whole life. The one she asked me to bury with her.”
He blinked. “What about it?”
“Will’s fiancée was wearing it.”
Something moved behind his eyes. He leaned back and crossed his arms. “That’s not possible. You buried it.”
“I thought I did,” I said. “So tell me how it ended up in someone else’s hands.”
“That’s not possible. You buried it.”
“Maureen, I don’t know what you’re talking about.”
“Her father told me he bought it from a business partner 25 years ago,” I explained. “For $25,000. The man told him it was a generational lucky charm.” I kept my eyes on his face. “He told me the man’s name.”
“Wait,” Dan was stunned. “Claire’s father?”
“Yes.”
Dan said nothing. He pressed his lips together and looked at the table, and in that moment he looked less like my 50-something brother and more like the teenager who used to get caught doing things he knew better than to do.
“He told me the man’s name.”
“It was just going into the ground, Maureen,” he said finally, his voice dropping. “Mom was going to bury it. It would’ve been gone forever.”
“What did you do, Dan?”
“I went into Mom’s room the night before her funeral and swapped it with a replica,” he confessed. “I overheard her asking you to bury it with her. I couldn’t believe she wanted it in the ground.”
He rubbed a hand over his face. “I had the necklace appraised. They told me what it was worth, and I thought… it was being wasted. That at least one of us should get something from it.”
“Mom never asked you what she’d want,” I retorted. “She asked me.”
He couldn’t answer that. I let the silence do what words couldn’t.
“I couldn’t believe she wanted it in the ground.”
When he finally apologized, it came out slowly, without any of the usual deflection. No “but you have to understand” attached to the end of it.
Just sorry, plainly meant, which was the only version I could do anything with.
I left his house with my heart heavier than when I’d walked in and drove home.
I’d always known the boxes were up there in the attic. Old things from my mother’s house — books, letters, and small objects that accumulate across a life.
I’d always known the boxes were up there in the attic.
